The following guest post was written by Michael, who is the founder of Credit Card Forum.

Near the end of 2010, the former President of Shell Oil predicted that U.S. gas prices could reach $5 per gallon by 2012. A lot of industry analysts are making similar predictions due to the economic recovery and surging demand from countries like China and India. But let’s not forget some of these same people were telling us in July of 2008 that gas would hit $7 the following year… obviously that never happened!

I don’t know which predictions will come true, but what I do know is that gas of around $3 (or higher) seems to be here to stay… or at least it looks that way for 2011. But whether it’s $2 or $5 per gallon, gas credit cards can be a great way to shave a little off the price. However not all of them are a good deal. Here are some things to consider when picking one out…

Station Specific vs. All Gas Stations?

Gas reward credit cards basically fall under two categories… those that only give rewards at an affiliated station (i.e. BP gas stations only) and those which are not affiliated with any specific brand of gas and give rewards at all stations. Both types have their pros and cons.

Obviously the benefit of a universal gas card is that you are not restricted to a specific brand of gas in order to earn rewards. This is especially helpful when you consider that the “name brand” stations usually cost more anyway. However, the downside is that they usually give a lower rebate (typically 3% or less) and there usually are caps on the amount of rewards you can earn.

On the other hand, a few gas station affiliated cards offer rewards of up to 5% on their gas, with no caps on the amount you can earn. If you usually buy that brand of gas, then it would probably be the way to go. But I would like to point out that the vast majority of station affiliated cards actually offer no rewards at all – most of them are not major credit cards and are geared towards with bad credit who can’t get approved for a normal credit card.

High Rebate Station-Specific Gas Credit Cards

Here are some that offer higher rebates at their affiliated stations. Please note that the rewards information was current as of January 2011 but of course it could change at any time:

Chase BP Visa

5% at BP gas stations, 2% on eligible dining and travel, 1% on other purchases, no annual fee, no caps on rewards

Sidenote: Many Americans don’t like the idea of giving BP their money right now (and understandably so!) but regardless of how you feel, there’s no denying this is a pretty darn attractive rewards program. I just wrote a review of the BP gas credit card a few weeks ago which goes over it in detail. I would also like to point out that this credit card is not on the advertising networks, so at the time of writing I’m not getting any kickbacks for promoting it – I just honestly feel the BP gas credit card has one of the better reward programs in this category.

Chase Marathon Platinum MasterCard

5% at Marathon stations, 1% on other purchases, no annual fee, no caps on rewards

Shell Platinum MasterCard

5% at Shell gas stations, 0.5% on other purchases, no annual fee, a maximum of $20 in rewards can be earned each month

Chevron Visa Card

10 cents/gallon on Chevron and Texaco gas (which equals a 3.33% rebate on $3 gas), 3% on non-fuel purchases at Chevron and Texaco, 1% everywhere else, a maximum of $300 in fuel credits can be earned per year

Phillips 66/Conoco 76 Platinum MasterCard

4% rebate at their stations, on other spending you get 0.5% on the first $5,000 spent each year and 1% on spending above that, no annual fee, a maximum of $50 can be earned each billing cycle

High Rebate Universal Gas Credit Cards

To be honest, the best gas credit cards in this category aren’t nearly as good as the ones previously available. During the years leading up to the gas price hysteria in 2008, there were a few gas credit cards that gave 5% at every station with no caps. Since 2008, many of them have reduced the rewards and implemented caps. Please note that my site Credit Card Forum does advertise most of the cards mentioned below, so to be transparent I just want to point out that there is a financial tie I have with them.

American Express Blue Cash

This is the only card on the market that still gives an unlimited 5% on gas (not to mention, grocery stores and drugstores) and 1.5% on other purchases. However you only get that after you spend $6,500 each year. Spending below that amount only earns you 1% on those 3 categories and 0.5% on everything else. There is no annual fee. Make sure you read a review of it before applying so you fully understand the details of the tiered reward system.

American Express TrueEarnings Costco card

If you are a Costco member this card has no annual fee. On the first $3,000 in fuel purchases each year it gives a 3% rebate. Other rewards include 3% at restaurants, 2% on travel, 1% everywhere else.

Discover More and Chase Freedom

I’m pairing these together because they operate in a very similar manner. Both give 5% on categories which typically rotate every quarter, up to whatever the quarterly cap may be. Unfortunately, there is usually only 5% at gas stations for one or two quarters out of the year on each card. However their 5% schedules don’t always overlap, hence if you don’t mind a wallet full of plastic you could strategically alternate between the Chase Freedom and the Discover More to possibly get the 5% on gas for a bigger chunk of the year (I have done this but it’s probably not worth the hassle for most people). Both the Chase Freedom and Discover More have no annual fee.

Capital One Cash Rewards

2% at gas stations and “major” grocery stores (I do not know exactly what’s considered “major”), 1% on other purchases, no annual fee, no rewards cap


This post was written by Michael, who is the founder of Credit Card Forum – a forum and blog for reviews of the best credit cards, as well as the worst.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Get future posts delivered directly to your inbox!

20 Comments Guest on Jan 17th 2011

20 Responses to “What Are The Best Gas Credit Cards For 2011?”

  1. Love my American Express Blue Cash card. Just got my 1200 dollar credit on my Christmas credit card bill!

  2. MBNA Smart Cash Platinum Mastercard 3% on gas groceries 1% on eveything else. $600 for gas/groceries.

  3. krantcents says:

    Personally, I like the Costco card because the Costco stations also have the lowest prices in the area. I think that is as important as the rebate.

  4. Jenna says:

    What about writing a blog post on alternatives ways to commute that save money rather than ways to save money on something expensive? Does the average reader drive that much that is makes sense to have a gas credit card?

  5. American Express Blue for me. Love that 5% cash back.

  6. Jessica07 says:

    I live 20 miles from town, so I’m all about saving money on fuel costs. My car gets 36mpg, but those miles and gallons add up rather quickly. I appreciate you taking the time to share this information. You might also check out of store-specific (not station-specific) credit cards also offer a store rewards option. For instance, Cabela’s offers 2% in rewards when you purchase fuel at a Cenex. My husband and I do a lot of camping, so this is a great way to save on fuel to put directly towards splurge… helps us keep balance on fun and savings. :)

  7. The PenFed Visa (Pentagon Federal Credit Union) is by far my winner. 5% cash back on all gas, 2% on all groceries, and 1% on everything else and NO MINIMUMS! :-)

  8. Thanks for the comments everyone!

    @Budgeting in the Fun Stuff: Yes you are absolutely right, the PenFed card totally slipped my mind while I was writing this. I love that card!

    @Jessica07: I love Cabelas but I’m not too impressed with their rewards (I think they could be a higher). There are actually a few cards on the market that give 2% everywhere like the Fidelity Retirement Rewards, Discover Escape, Cap One Venture, etc.

    @Jenna: That would be a great topic to write about!

  9. I think the BP card is best. I figure they are trying to win back a few of the customers they lost last year.

  10. Mark says:

    I agree with Derek. I think that the BP card is the best deal going for gas.

  11. Michael, you’re awesome! You’re like the credit card Guru!

    I would like to advocate for a Canadian card- PetroCanada Mastercard. You get a 1:1 conversion with Asia Miles (Cathay Pacific Airlines) for $0 annual fee.

    With an Asia Miles credit card, you have to pay a $120 a year fee to get that same 1:1 conversion!

    I don’t have the Petrocanada card because I have way too many mastercards already, but it would be one of my favourites should my MBNA Travel Rewards suck later on.

  12. Excellent, detailed post. I am considering a new CC and if I do, I’ll probably select one from this list. Thanks for the details!

    Mark

  13. What Are The Best Gas Credit Cards For 2011? | Invest It Wisely says:

    [...] What Are The Best Gas Credit Cards For 2011? | Invest It Wisely I would also like to point out that this credit card is not on the advertising networks, so at the time of writing I’m not getting any kickbacks for promoting it – I just honestly feel the BP gas credit card has one of the better reward … gas credit cards bp – Google Blog Search [...]

  14. Thanks, I’m glad you guys like the post!

    @youngandthrifty – What a pleasant surprise to bump into you again so soon :) That PetroCanada Mastercard does sound like an excellent idea if you fly that airline.

    “I don’t have the Petrocanada card because I have way too many mastercards already”

    Screw MasterCard… stick with your Starwood Amex :)

  15. Moneycone says:

    I’m gonna go with PenFed. 5% on gas at any gas station is hard to beat!

  16. Kevin says:

    Thanks for all of the great comments everyone, and thanks for the great post, Mike!

  17. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Adysin Montgomery, Dale Kirk. Dale Kirk said: What Are The Best Gas Credit Cards For 2011? | Invest It Wisely: But whether it's $2 or $5 per gallon, gas credi… http://bit.ly/hjoXZl [...]

  18. [...] What Are The Best Gas Credit Cards For 2011? [...]

  19. iritated says:

    Just got a letter from Citibank / Shell that there are significant changes to the Shell Platinum Mastercard effective July of 2011. Autopay no longer available. You have to make qualifying purchases totaling $500 or more in single billing cycle to get a credit. You only get credit on first 100 gallons. The credit is only $0.10 per gallon assuming qualifying purchases between $500 – $999. So basically I not be making any more purchases and will close the account after I get my final credit under the old plan.