• Home
  • About
  • Recommended Reading
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise / Contact

Invest It Wisely

Maximizing your EV in life

  • Home
  • Growing Your Wealth
  • Small Business Solutions
  • Healthy Living
  • Miscellaneous

How Gold Can Provide Stratospheric Returns to Your Investment Portfolio… if You Can Avoid the Bubbles!

By Kevin

A while ago, I took a look at the performance of gold over the past few decades, and I recently looked at the hot activity in precious metals. There was a great discussion on that post on the merits of investing in gold versus the stock market, and fellow bloggers shared their views on the fundamentals behind the recent price rise and where it’s going to go next.

I don’t generally believe in short-term market timing; I did recently sell off a portion of my precious metals, but I did it both on the basis that there was a little too much fear & greed going around last week and on the basis that my current plan is to stick to a 10% asset allocation in precious metals. Otherwise, I concede that short-term timing is probably not much different than playing craps at the casino. How about long-term timing based on fundamentals?

The analysis

Here are the assumptions:

  • I will compare the performance of gold against the total returns of the Wilshire 5000 stock market index, which tracks the returns of all stocks actively traded in the U.S. markets.
  • Starting in 1975, our fictional investor will invest $1 000 in gold every year, at the beginning of the year, at the London P.M fix price. This $1 000 will increase by 3% per year.
  • The same amount of cash will also be invested in units of the Wilshire 5000 index.
  • There is also a third scenario for our savvy investor. He will switch his portfolio between gold and the Wilshire 5000, at these times:
    • 1978: Switch from the market to gold.
    • 1981: Switch from gold to the market.
    • 2001: Switch from the market back to gold.
  • I’ll also look at the case where our investor switches a couple of years later, after the bubbles have burst.

Sources for the following analysis:

  • Gold prices from Kitco, based on the London PM fix.
  • Wilshire 5000 index values from Wilshire, historical index values.

Here is the basic analysis for investing in gold versus the Wilshire 5000:

Chart of gold versus the Wilshire 5000, nominal value, annual investments from 1975 to 2010.

So as we can see, the stock market has performed better than gold when invested in regularly over the past 35 years. However, what if our investor was prescient enough to shift his portfolio between the stock market and gold whenever he sensed a bubble coming? Well, his returns can be seen in the following chart:

Chart of gold versus the Wilshire 5000 versus market timing, nominal value, annual investments from 1975 to 2010.

By switching between the stock market and gold at the moments before each bubble burst, our investor has drastically increased his total returns. What if he hadn’t had such good foresight in selling, and only got out two years later, after each bubble burst?

Chart of Gold Versus Wilshire 5000 Versus Bad Market Timing, Nominal Value, 1975-2010

Our investor’s returns are demolished, but interestingly, he still ended up better off than he would have had he stuck 100% to gold! This kind of result might be typical if you let your fear & greed get the best of you and try to chase your losses after going through a collapse. While this market timing strategy can be rather risky, there is no need to commit your entire portfolio to this risk. Just investing 20% of income into a gold-or-stock strategy is sufficient to greatly increase returns, if you sell before the bubble bursts:

Chart of a comparison of income allocation strategies; 100% Wilshire 5000 versus 80% Wilshire 5000 and 20% gold market timing, nominal value from 1975 to 2010

It is very easy to talk about bubbles in hindsight, but how can we detect one while it is in progress? The first gold bubble saw the gold price increasing by more than 100% in a year; the Wilshire 5000 had a few stellar years of 25%+ before declining. Here are a couple of ratios which show the relation between gold and the Wilshire 5000 over the past 35 years:

Gold/Wilshire 5000 Ratio; 1975-2010

Wilshire 5000/Gold Ratio; 1975-2010

The results

Overall compound annual growth rates (CAGRs) of the various strategies:

Overall CAGR, 1975-2010
Gold 6.6%
Bad market timing 9.4%
Wilshire 5000 10.1%
80% Wilshire 5000; 20% Gold market timing 13.1%
Gold market timing 17.6%

The trick is avoiding the burst 🙂 For the next post in this series, I’ll look at more investment strategies, both with and without timing. So, reader, what do you think? Maybe the 1980 bubble would have been easy to avoid after a 150% rise, but what were the signs of the subsequent malinvestments?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Filed Under: Growing Your Wealth, Investing, Market Analysis, Opinion, Precious Metals Tagged With: gold, market timing, planning, speculative bubble, Wilshire 5000

About Kevin

Kevin has left the office, and he is currently fighting the rat race by working on his own business. He enjoys exploring unvisited places around the world and gaining new experiences. He believes that by properly managing our energy and time, we can learn to invest our lives wisely.

Comments

  1. Mich @ BTI says

    May 19, 2010 at 1:48 pm

    Market Timing, is it possible? that is the question. I do not believe in market timing, i think controlling your greed and locking in profits is far more profitable than riding a bubble and ending up in a loss.
    .-= Mich @ BTI´s last blog ..Stock Trades: Sold TSE:FVI (Silver) =-.

  2. Kevin says

    May 21, 2010 at 9:48 am

    Good point Mich; I’m going to do a follow up that shows what happens when you switch in relation to the bursting bubble.

  3. 101centavos says

    November 5, 2010 at 10:23 am

    I have two precious metal funds in the self-directed portion of my 401k. So far, they’ve done fairly well. As the old saying goes though, we shouldn’t confuse a bull market for brains.

    • Kevin says

      November 8, 2010 at 3:16 pm

      Interesting thoughts, especially now that we see gold hitting 1400. I think that an asset allocation strategy might be the best way to avoid falling subject to emotions. Now that the values are this high, I am a little fearful. I will not be selling off or anything; I am sticking to my strategy. I certainly don’t see prices as a bargain anymore, though.

  4. donate japan earthquake one says

    March 14, 2011 at 7:53 am

    Who wants to support donate to Japan?
    It’s’ very unfortunate as to what’s happening in Japan, so assist donate!
    Japan demands your own help!

Trackbacks

  1. Beating The Index: Weekend Edition | BeatingTheIndex.com says:
    May 22, 2010 at 7:47 am

    […] #1 How Gold Can Provide Stratospheric Returns to Your Investment Portfolio… if You Can Avoid the Bubb… […]

  2. The Month in Review | Invest It Wisely says:
    May 31, 2010 at 10:06 am

    […] How Gold Can Provide Stratospheric Returns to Your Investment Portfolio… if You Can Avoid the Bubb… […]

  3. Living to 100 and Beyond: Building Your Portfolio | Invest It Wisely says:
    June 1, 2010 at 9:48 am

    […] and 10% of my investments in precious metals. See Gold as an Investment: Performance over Time and How Gold Can Provide Stratospheric Returns to Your Investment Portfolio… if You Can Avoid the Bubb… for a more detailed analysis on this […]

  4. Gold Investment Strategies – Latest Gold Investment Strategies news – Tuesday Morning Chartology & Subscriber Alert says:
    October 2, 2010 at 7:51 pm

    […] How Gold Can Provide Stratospheric Returns to Your Investment … […]

  5. Gold as an Investment: Performance over Time | Invest It Wisely says:
    October 5, 2010 at 1:53 pm

    […] market. How can this be possible? Gold normally just sits there, looking pretty. How could it have given more value on your money than the entire ensemble of public companies and workers, working hard to produce the goods and […]

About Invest It Wisely

Invest It Wisely is about evaluating the choices that each of us face everyday. It’s about investing your time, your money, and your energy wisely, in order to achieve your goals. The end goal is maximizing your life expectation, and exploring the ways to get there.

Subscribe!

Subscribe via RSSSubscribe via EmailSubscribe via TwitterSubscribe via Facebook

Most Popular Posts

  • How to Get Fit, Feel Better, and Get Rid of Your Foggy Head: A Few Simple Steps
  • 3 Frugal Ideas for a Romantic Valentine’s Day
  • What Would You Do with a Million Dollars?
  • The Importance of Opportunity Costs, and Why They Should Not Be Ignored
  • What Do You Need to Get out of the Rat Race and Achieve Financial Freedom?

Categories

  • Avoiding Scams
  • Book Reviews
  • Crypto Trading
  • Currency Trading
  • Economics
  • Financial Freedom
  • General Reviews
  • Growing Your Wealth
  • Healthy Living
  • Insurance
  • Interviews
  • Investing
  • Market Analysis
  • Miscellaneous
  • Motivation
  • Opinion
  • Paying Down Debt
  • Philosophy
  • Precious Metals
  • Reader Questions
  • Real Estate
  • Relationships
  • Saving Your Money
  • Small Business Solutions
  • Stories
  • Uncategorized
  • Weekend Reading

Archives

Invest It Wisely Copyright © 2016
Creative Commons License
This work by Invest It Wisely is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at http://www.investitwisely.com/contact